
The emphasis on human dignity in Catholic social teaching and the Thomistic notion of rightly ordered action may offer a guide for solving issues of “disordered passivity” and “cynical apathy” among youth, according to a widely celebrated lecturer at The Catholic University of America (CUA).
Yuval Levin — director of social, cultural, and constitutional studies at The American Enterprise Institute — made this case at the fifth annual Lecture on Catholic Political Thought, organized by CUA’s Gibbons Institute and the Center for the Constitution and the Catholic Intellectual Tradition.
Levin, who is Jewish, said he was invited to deliver the Nov. 19 speech because the intention this year was to host a speaker who could reflect on the Catholic political tradition from the perspective of “a non-Catholic’s and outsider’s point of view.”
“I am a non-Catholic who has long taken a great and very grateful interest in the tradition of Catholic political and social thought, and benefited enormously from it,” he said.
In his address, Levin pointed to an issue he said “runs awfully deep in the 21st-century West,” arguing that it “runs much deeper” than political dysfunction, the idolatry of technology, and the development of artificial intelligence and social media, though these issues are connected to it.
“It runs so deep that itʼs hard for us to isolate it and name it,” he said “But if I were to give it a name, I would call it something like disordered passivity.”
Levin said through history, “weʼve understood social breakdown as essentially a function of excess,” specifically “vice without the guardrails of family and faith and work.” Yet, in the last quarter-century, the challenges “seem less like exorbitant human desires” and “more like an absence of energy and drive.”
Levin said through history, “weʼve understood social breakdown as essentially a function of excess,” specifically “vice without the guardrails of family and faith and work.” Yet, in the last quarter-century, the challenges “seem less like exorbitant human desires” and “more like an absence of energy and drive.”
“[This is] leaving people languishing, withering on the vine, spectators more than actors in the life of our society, and even in their own lives in various ways,” he said. “There is less and less of a need to tell young Americans to slow down or back off or abstain, or just say no. … Thereʼs more and more of a need to tell them to take risks, to make choices, to get going, to say yes to life.”
Levin said many young people “see the problem, but not quite the solution.” He said “what [society] lacks, above all, is a sense of the moral order.” He pointed toward a Catholic and Thomistic notion of rightly ordered action and virtue.
“A vitalism that just mirrors our passivity, that answers emptiness with raw appetite, that mistakes aggression for agency is not the cure for that condition,” he said. “Itʼs a kind of symptom of it. Rightly ordered action is the missing ingredient in the contemporary quest for happiness. “
Levin also noted that Catholic social teaching’s specific focus on the dignity of the human person is helpful in addressing many social problems, adding that the teaching is “rooted in the fact that we are created in a divine image, and from that deep root grow commitments to solidarity and subsidiarity and the common good.”
“The engagement with novel challenges begins from a restatement of these enduring commitments, and only then proceeds to diagnosis and prescription, and that allows it to take on unfamiliar problems in a way that is confident and sophisticated, yet is not arrogant or technocratic,” he said. “Itʼs an extraordinary gift to the world.”
The Gibbons Institute
The James Cardinal Gibbons Institute for Human Ecology, which was originally just called the Institute for Human Ecology, was renamed to honor the cardinal who helped found the university in 1887.
Catherine Pakaluk, the executive director of the institute, told EWTN News it was renamed because many people “donʼt know the riches of our founding era,” calling Gibbons a “great figure,” adding: “The more I read in his corpus of works the more impressed I was with the kind of man he was.”
The institute has 24 faculty fellows who contribute elements of their research. The institute is interdisciplinary, which means it covers a wide range of Catholic thought, including history, philosophy, and theology.
The Gibbons Institute publishes the American Catholic Quarterly Review.

Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.