Authorities in the central Vietnamese city of Hue have demolished a building on land the Redemptorists say they have owned since 1930, and the order is demanding that officials disclose the legal grounds for the move.
Father Joseph Pham Quoc Giang, rector of the Redemptorists’ Hue parish, described the operation in a Nov. 19 report to Archbishop Joseph Dang Duc Ngan of Hue, the archdiocese’s clergy and the Redemptorist province.
EWTN News has obtained a copy of the report.
Early on Nov. 17, while the Hue Redemptorists were attending their provincial chapter in Saigon, city authorities deployed mobile police, traffic police, security personnel, civil defense officers, and local militia to block all roads leading to the church, the monastery, and the L’Accueil building at 87 Nguyen Hue St., Giang wrote.
He said electricity and internet access in the area were cut and Wi-Fi signals disrupted and that many parishioners were unable to attend Mass.

Cranes, dump trucks, excavators, and other heavy machinery worked on the demolition day and night on Nov. 17 and 18, according to the report. By the morning of Nov. 19, he wrote, the checkpoints had been removed, the machinery and workers had withdrawn, and the site had been leveled and fenced off.
‘Concerns remain unresolved’
The provincial chapter of the Redemptorists of Vietnam said on Nov. 17 that it “strongly condemns and resolutely opposes this action.”
“The Redemptorists have never voluntarily donated, transferred, or relinquished their land-use rights to this property to any person or entity,” the statement said. It demanded that “the competent authorities publicly disclose the legal grounds for the demolition.”
“Justice cannot be established through force, and the truth cannot be erased along with the structures that have been demolished,” the chapter added.
Father Augustino Le Quy Phi, writing on behalf of the provincial superior, Father Dominic Nguyen Duc Thong, told EWTN News in an email on Nov. 20 that “following the demolition of the L’Accueil building, our concerns remain unresolved.”
“Although the authorities have come to negotiate with us, they have yet to provide an official response or clarify the legal grounds for their actions, despite our previous requests,” he wrote. “We continue to seek justice, transparency, and a fair resolution through peaceful and lawful means.”
On Nov. 19, Redemptorist priests from Ha Tinh celebrated Mass with the Hue community, and the provincial superior joined the prayers that afternoon, the order said.

A notice posted at the site in October announced a public park with a parking lot, according to the order. Hue state media reported on Nov. 16 that the standing committee of the city’s Communist Party committee had approved the park in June, citing dense housing, narrow lanes, and rush-hour traffic.
Police-run Facebook pages in Hue defended the plan, The Vietnamese Magazine reported. One ward police page argued on Nov. 17 that past use of a property does not automatically give a right to reclaim it.
On Nov. 18, a Hue police youth page posted a video citing a 2003 National Assembly resolution, Nguoi Viet and The Vietnamese Magazine reported. Under that resolution, the state does not reconsider its housing and land policies issued before July 1, 1991, or recognize claims to recover property it managed under them.
According to the order, an Oct. 27 letter from the Hue People’s Committee cited a 1975 letter from then-Archbishop Nguyen Kim Dien of Hue as one basis for concluding that the property had been handed over to the state. The order says that letter named only the L’Accueil library, at a different street address, and that the archbishop did not automatically have authority over the order’s property.
In a Nov. 8 letter, the provincial superior said city authorities had told the order its Oct. 24 complaint had no basis for consideration, The Vietnamese Magazine and Nguoi Viet reported.
The order has also taken its case to Archbishop Marek Zalewski, the resident papal representative in Vietnam, according to letters the order supplied to EWTN News.
In a formal submission dated Nov. 5, the provincial superior asked for the archbishop’s prayers and, if he considered it appropriate, for help in encouraging the authorities to consider the historical and legal issues.
That submission also says a delegation led by Nguyen Van Manh, vice chairman of the Hue People’s Committee, visited the community on Oct. 28 and that “both parties exchanged views on the property and its legal status.”
In a follow-up dated Nov. 18, the provincial wrote: “I am deeply grateful that Your Excellency has received my letter concerning the L’Accueil property, the legitimate property of the Redemptorist Congregation, and forwarded it to the competent authorities.”
The same letter says that on Nov. 9, Father Giang, as superior of the Hue monastery, petitioned the Hue People’s Committee, “requesting that no construction work of any kind be carried out on the L’Accueil property and that the legal basis and status of the property be clarified together with us.”
Some people backed the demolition on social media, saying the old building had deteriorated and that the park would ease traffic and add green space, UCA News reported.
Background
The Redemptorists said they bought the land at auction in 1930 through the Mission Apostolique de Hue and that Hue City Hall confirmed their ownership on July 10, 1971.
In 1978, under pressure from the authorities, the community applied to donate the assets of a sawmill it ran on the land to the state, the order says. Giang told UCA News that the donation “did not mean the congregation had voluntarily surrendered the land.”
The remaining L’Accueil plot of about 27,500 square feet (2,550 square meters) is managed by a Hue sports vocational school.
The Redemptorists said they have petitioned for its return since 1994, most recently in an Oct. 24 complaint to the Hue People’s Committee asking for the land-use rights and formal title to the land.
Under Vietnamese law, all land is owned by the people as a whole, with the state managing it on their behalf.
